It’s a fact: new moms judge other moms about their parenting choices. I’ve been there, I know. I’m ashamed to admit, I even lost friends over it. Nearly 7 years later, I can finally understand it more objectively, but it still perplexes and angers me that educated, intelligent women are fighting over how they “should” care for their babies.

Why should you care if your friend co-sleeps and quit her day job to be a full-time, baby-wearing mom? And why should she judge you for sleep-training your baby, and going back to your full-time day job? Is it simply because we’re so insecure about our own choices? Are we so afraid of doing something "wrong" that we judge others because they believe a different method or theory or author? Can we blame baby theory “experts” for pitting moms against mom in these theoretical wars, or do we blame ourselves for falling prey to this bourgeois pettiness?  

In Attachment Parenting or The Alternative, I write about how opposing parenting theories are confusing new parents more than ever. I would further argue that this trend is divisive amongst women. Megan Francis, author of The Happiest Mom, writes a humbling account about her struggle to find her own parenting style in a piece, On Labels and Limits: Why I No Longer Call Myself an Attachment Parent.

There’s a lot of buzz in the Mommy-sphere about how moms are divided and feuding over parenting choices. Leslie Morgan Steiner’s book, Mommy Wars: Stay at Home and Career Moms Face Off on Their Choices, Their Lives, Their Families is a perfect example. It's all shockingly true, and it fries my feminist feathers! Why on earth do women compete about how their kids sleep, or for how long they breastfeed? Sorry Ladies, but I grew up knee-deep in 70’s feminist ideals, and I just don’t get it. What happened to Sisterhood?

I’d love to hear from you about this. Have you lost any friends, or are you at risk of losing any friends over your parenting choices?  Please share your experiences! And most importantly, WHAT CAN WE DO RIGHT NOW to make this a better, more supportive world for all moms?


 


Comments

GM
08/03/2011 11:00am

Yep, I just lost two friends this past weekend because my 2.5 year old bit a friend's 6 month old baby. They had been playing nicely and it happened in a millisecond. So my friend blames me because I was in the room and should have been able to stop it from happening. Then anouther mutual friend arrived (who doesn't even have kids) and said that the only reason kids bite is because they don't feel they are getting enough attention from their parents, therefore I am not giving him enough attention. She then went on to say that because my 6 year old is a loud talker is because he must feel "ignored" by me. He's always been a loud talker, and probably because I have a severe hearing problem so he's learned so speak loudly. Yep, this 'friend' felt it was entirely appropriate to say that I am not giving my kids enough attention, positive reinforcement, and that I'm out and out ignoring them. The best part about this is that she's only been with me and my kids about 3x in the last year for about 20 minutes each time. So yep, I have decided that I don't need this type of 'friend' in my life. I adore my kids and do the best job i can every single day of caring for them. I am simply amazed that another woman feels it's appropriate to judge someone else's parenting choices.

Reply
08/03/2011 2:06pm

Oh no, that's terrible! So sorry to hear, but I'm sad to say that I've been through, and heard, so many similar situations. It's easy to judge others without a thought, but I've learned the hard way. When in doubt, I keep my mouth shut, and whenever I have the opportunity, I try to be supportive of all parents. We're all just doing our best!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply